Open Letter to LAUSD Superintendent John Deasy

A parent of two middle school students at Palms Middle School sends an open letter to Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent John Deasy.

Dear Dr Deasy:

She told us she'd go down with the ship, ... but you've forced her to walk the gang plank.


You have on Los Angeles' very own Westside, snuggled smack dab within the boundaries of LAUSD District 3, a "Model School Of Excellence" by your very own designation.

Palms Middle School is a learning community of identified gifted-learners (GATES) and local neighborhood learners all rolled into three fabulous, seamless, Schools That Work. Children at Palms Middle School are learning by any measure you take, and measure them you have.  They spend an inordinate percentage of their school lives being sized up and scrutinized and measured out for the tailored suit of standardized rote learning that cloaks them.  And yet, despite so many self-indulgent metrices, the endless gauging, plumbing and measuring, you seem never quite to have *noticed* the results of your tests.

Right here in your midst lies Palms Middle School, the very shining paradigm of a SCHOOL THAT IS WORKING.  Children are learning, their test scores are high, and climbing steadily upward every year, importantly among every socioeconomic and scholastic strata. Any way you look at it, the entire school shows consistent, impressive gains. While other local charter schools may claim higher overall scores, these are average numbers that do not stand up to strata-specific scrutiny.

Palms Middle School educates children, and educates them better than others, regardless of socioeconomic status. This is a truly egalitarian school, truly diverse and integrated. By collecting together in one vessel so many excellent students and teachers in an atmosphere of high expectation, superior pedagogy and committed involvement, absolutely everyone's boat floats here: gifted, special-needs, rich and poor alike. This is not a rarefied community of economically or academically pre-selected, privileged learners; it is a school where very nearly half the students are Title I compliant (i.e., "poor"); an authentic slice of the city. The children here are happy, they are healthy and friendly and accomplished.  This institution is a blazing success story by any metric you care to engage.

But. Has anyone noticed??? Have YOU noticed? 

Because while you have been out patrolling whole school communities closed down for the sins of one or two among them, behind and beneath your gaze has been this - and likely several other - schools where competence has been eked from pitifully inadequate budgets year after year after year:  to your utter and willful disregard.

Sending insult after injury, you have squeezed this school's budget dryer than a skeleton core, and then extracted its entitled Title I funding as well, sending an administrative pall overnight of the loss of hundreds of thousands of dollars onto the sodden desk of the principal.  After forcing her to do with less and less until there was no more to do less with, you then cut into her work staff, the vaunted vital "team" of support staff so highly extolled by you for your own needs.  Not satisfied with weakening her ship to this dangerous degree, you have sent this 35 year public school inspirational veteran of alchemic miracles, notice that she may be hired back after RIF-ing, but only at reduced personal salary.       

But here's the thing.  This is an administrator who has commanded a ship that works, Excellently -- and you very simply have just not noticed.  Never have you asked:  What is Working here. Never have you visited.  Never have you investigated what principles, skills, tools, techniques have rendered this school such an admirable well-oiled "School Of Excellence" (LAUSD's designation).  Instead of honoring, scrutinizing and studying this venerable institution that is performing so excellently, you are willfully sabotaging the ship. You have withdrawn vital monies.  You have removed critical staff and faculty.  You have even whittled away at the personal salary of the one you are requiring ever-more work of amidst infinitely fewer resources.    

You have forced Palms Middle Schools' principal to walk the plank and she has jumped.  She has jumped ship, leaving us rudderless.     

This is more than a tragedy, it is censurable and unconscionable.  As a parent, I am appealing to you personally, entreating that you inquire after the means of excellence of this school immediately, yesterday - before it is too late.  There is a treasure trove of excellence housed within this school in the form of its principal and much support staff as well that you seem poised to permit to disperse heedlessly.  This is not acceptable.  Excellence is not so easily achieved that we any of us can afford to let it dissipate.

PLEASE PAY ATTENTION to the constituents of Palms Middle School that are working.  Do not permit its principal to be lost to us.  Do not dismiss vital support staff and slash its budget and faculty.  This ship is foundered and can sustain no more insult. SAVE OUR SHIP.  Sustain Palms Middle School.

Tuco May 23, 2012 at 03:14 AM
The whole LAUSD need to go. Broken up and give to the privite sector.
Joseph K July 11, 2012 at 07:25 AM
Everyone should read "Deasy Must Go" (the above link). "Terrifying" is more like it.
Joseph K July 11, 2012 at 07:46 AM
Measuring Palms students has always been misleading. Many, many of the teachers are absolutely wonderful. I taught there for many years and am extremely proud of my efforts, the achievements of my students, and every one of my colleagues. But their test scores are camouflaged by the fact they have so many "gifted and high achieving" magnet students (a very elitist, exclusionary system), whose high test scores mask the mediocre results of all the "ungifted" minority children attending Palms' "regular" Middle School. No matter how much we try, we simply don't have a reliable, reproducible strategy to deal with poverty and the achievement chasm poverty creates -at least not one anyone is willing to fund adequately. In the meantime, can we please stop measuring the quality of instruction and learning, you know, the kinds that really matter, by a single standardized test score? This test obsession is destroying quality instruction as described above. Sign the National Resolution on High Stakes Testing. Pass this link to your friends. http://timeoutfromtesting.org/nationalresolution/
Nobama July 11, 2012 at 10:43 PM
Judging by the butchery of the English language exhibited in some of these posts, the changes are justified.
Rene Diedrich July 12, 2012 at 01:10 AM
Please identify the errors that are not typos. Have you ever been in a hurry and tried to bang out a comment on a cell phone. No easy task. Deasy would not be to blame for our lapse in grammar and mechanics, which really are the least of our concerns with small children being molested, billions being wasted or embezzled and Belmont HS a major disaster waiting to happen. "The Grammarian's Funeral" is a great poem Robert Browning wrote for those who get caught up in such things. Maybe you ought to read it and add a little Literature to your skill set. Twain wouldn't hurt while you're at it. Even though I am guilty of more than my fair share of errors, I would agree with you if this wasn't an informal forum. Your grammar and punctuation must be perfect if you're writing an academic paper, resume or other document that is professional. In these posts people are colloquial , maybe a little careless. That is why I think these responses are so enjoyable. Unlike you, I am not interested in feeling superior because of an oversight or writing little quips that are intended to represent wit, I just like regional dialects and linquistic quirks. Lighten up.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »